Courtyard vs Arena Club at a glance
| Feature | Courtyard | Arena Club |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 4.5 / 5 | 2.5 / 5 |
| Games | Pokémon, One Piece, sports cards, MTG and comics | sports cards and Pokémon |
| Pack prices | $25–$5,000 | $50–$250 |
| Instant buyback | 90% of market value in cash | 90% of market value in cash |
| Odds published | Yes | Yes |
| Provably fair | Unknown | Unknown |
| Vault | Yes | Yes |
| Trustpilot | 3.7 (797 reviews) | 1.7 (35 reviews) |
| Welcome offer | None right now | None right now |
| Type | Pokémon + other TCGs | Sports-first |
| Market position | Market leader | Established |
Packs and games
Courtyard sells Pokémon, One Piece, sports cards, MTG and comics packs priced $25–$5,000, while Arena Club sells sports cards and Pokémon packs priced $50–$250. Courtyard is a multi-TCG site, with Pokémon next to other card games, while Arena Club is a sports-card site that also sells Pokémon.
Fairness and trust
Courtyard: no public fairness proof, odds published before you buy, Trustpilot 3.7 from 797 reviews. Arena Club: no public fairness proof, odds published before you buy, Trustpilot 1.7 from 35 reviews.
Buyback and cash-out
Courtyard buys pulls back at 90% of market value in cash; Arena Club at 90% of market value in cash. Cash buybacks can be withdrawn, while credit only buys more packs.
Courtyard or Arena Club: which one to pick?
Pick Courtyard if…
- You want the higher-rated site overall.
- You want one of the market leaders, with the deepest card pools.
- You want cheaper entry packs (from $25).
- You want a long public track record of reviews.
Courtyard comes out ahead in our ratings (4.5 vs 2.5 out of 5), mainly on trust and fairness. Arena Club is still worth a look if the reasons above match how you play.
Full reviews: Courtyard review and promo code · Arena Club review and promo code
FAQ
Is Courtyard better than Arena Club?
In our ratings Courtyard scores higher (4.5 vs 2.5 out of 5). The best pick still depends on what you collect and whether you sell pulls back.
Which has the better buyback, Courtyard or Arena Club?
Courtyard: 90% of market value in cash. Arena Club: 90% of market value in cash. Cash buybacks are worth more than site credit, which can only buy more packs.
Can I use both Courtyard and Arena Club?
Yes. Each site has its own account, balance and welcome offer, so you can sign up to both and compare packs before you deposit more.